ICC Arbitration Rules 2026: Practical implications for Irish construction projects

The International Chamber of Commerce (“ICC”) has updated its Rules of Arbitration, with the revised rules (the “2026 Rules”) entering into force on 1 June 2026.

These changes are particularly timely and significant for parties operating in the Irish construction and infrastructure sectors because, as of 16 June 2026, the revised Capital Works Management Framework (“CWMF”) provides that ICC Arbitration Rules will apply by default to arbitration under the Public Works Contracts where parties have not elected to use the bespoke Arbitration Rules for use with Public Works and Construction Services Contracts (“AR1”).

As a result, there will be a growing number of disputes arising from Irish public infrastructure and construction projects that are now resolved under the ICC Rules. Whilst the 2026 Rules are best characterised as an evolution, rather than a wholesale rewrite of the Rules of Arbitration, this article will outline the key changes introduced by the 2026 Rules, including the now-optional Terms of Reference, the new opt in Highly Expedited Arbitration Provisions (HEAP), and the express mechanism for the early determination of unmeritorious claims.

  1. Why did the CWMF introduce the ICC Rules?

In July 2025, the Irish government launched a consultation aimed at gathering input on proposed changes to the dispute resolution provisions of the Public Works Contracts under the CWMF. One such proposal was the introduction of ‘institutional arbitration’ by the adoption of the ICC Rules of Arbitration.

In announcing this change, Minister for Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalistation, Jack Chambers, noted that the aim was to improve dispute management in public construction projects, and to support more timely and efficient infrastructure delivery. It was noted that the changes would strengthen the public works contracts through faster arbitration.

The updated provisions apply to public works contracts for projects over €1m. So, what are the key changes?

  1. The Case Management Conference is the Central Procedural Event

The 2026 Rules require that the initial Case Management Conference (“CMC”), a feature first introduced by the 2012 Rules, must now be held within 30 days of the tribunal receiving the file. This becomes the critical gateway for how the arbitration will be managed. At this conference, the procedural timetable, disclosure of documents, evidence protocols and hearing schedule are all fixed at this early stage.

Stakeholders should particularly take note that there is a prohibition on the introduction of new claims after the initial CMC without prior authorisation from the tribunal. This represents significant discipline on construction disputes. In complex projects, disputes frequently evolve, additional defects emerge, delay claims expand as programmes are updated, and variation negotiations are ongoing. The prohibition on late claims will require parties to engage substantively and strategically at a very early stage. The practical message here is clear: early case preparation, thorough document preservation from the outset of a project and a clear articulation of the full scope of the dispute at the CMC will all be essential.

  1. Terms of Reference No Longer Mandatory

One of the most structurally significant changes in the 2026 Rules is the removal of the mandatory requirement to draw up Terms of Reference. Terms of Reference were a defining characteristic of ICC arbitration for decades, typically setting out the parties’ claims, the relief sought and the procedural framework. In practice, many users found them costly and time-consuming to negotiate without materially narrowing the issues in dispute. Parties may still agree to produce Terms of Reference where considered useful for case management, however this departure under the 2026 Rules emphasises the likely future importance of the CMC.

  1. Early Determination of Claims

The express early determination procedure permits any party to apply to the tribunal for the summary dismissal of claims or defences that are “manifestly without merit” or “manifestly outside the tribunal’s jurisdiction”. The tribunal first decides whether to allow the application and, if it does, considers its merits. This two-step process is designed to prevent early determination from being weaponised as a delay tactic.

In the construction context, this is a valuable addition. Projects give rise to claims of widely varying merit, and the ability to dispose of unmeritorious claims or spurious jurisdictional objections without a full evidential hearing can reduce costs and compress timelines.

Top tip: parties seeking early determination should file promptly and set out clearly why a claim or defence falls below the “manifestly” threshold. The standard is intended to be a high one, and it is not a substitute for a full hearing on claims that genuinely require one.

  1. Highly Expedited Arbitration Provisions (HEAP)

The 2026 Rules introduce an entirely new HEAP procedure, which operates as an opt-in mechanism capable of delivering a final award within three months of the initial CMC. Key features include:

  • A sole arbitrator.
  • A documents-only procedure without hearings or witness examination, where appropriate.
  • The possibility for parties to agree to an award without reasons.
  • Compressed timetables with front-loaded submission.
  • No joinder / limited consolidation of related proceedings.

HEAP (irrespective of the amount in dispute) will be best suited for disputes with a straightforward factual matrix e.g. a discrete payment dispute, a single-issues defects claim or a clearly defined variation dispute. For the Irish construction industry, where projects frequently generate standalone disputes that are time-critical (particularly where works are ongoing and cash flow is affected), HEAP offers a genuinely attractive and cost-efficient option. It is, however, unsuitable for multi-party proceedings or disputes with significant factual complexity.

  1. Expedited Procedure: Increased Monetary Threshold

The existing Expedited Procedure (a fast-track mechanism limiting document exchange, restricting production, and compressing timelines) has been retained, but the monetary threshold for its automatic application has been increased from $3m to $4m for arbitration agreements concluded on or after 1 June 2026.

This reflects the rising value of international commercial disputes. Given the scale of many Irish public works and infrastructure contracts, this expanded eligibility is relevant for smaller disputes that would previously have fallen below the threshold.

  1. Arbitrator Independence, Impartiality and Disclosure

The 2026 Rules place a heightened emphasis on arbitrator independence and impartiality. Any doubts a prospective arbitrator has about whether to disclose a potential conflict must be resolved in favour of disclosure. Importantly, disclosure alone does not establish a lack of independence. Parties are now required to submit to the ICC Secretariat a list of persons and entities, with reasons, whom prospective arbitrators should consider for disclosure purposes.

This is of particular relevance to the construction, engineering, and infrastructure sectors in Ireland, which involve a relatively close-knit professional community. Experts, arbitrators, and party representatives frequently interact across multiple projects and proceedings. The enhanced disclosure framework reduces the risk of challenges to arbitrator appointments arising mid-proceedings, which can be costly and disruptive. Parties should take care when nominating arbitrators and when compiling their disclosure lists.

  1. Key Takeaways

The 2026 Rules represent a significant step forward in procedural efficiency and flexibility. The following are our key takeaways:

  • Review your contracts now: if your contracts incorporate the ICC Rules by reference, they will be subject to the 2026 Rules for any arbitration commenced on or after 1 June 2026.
  • Invest in document management from day one: the prohibition on new claims after the CMC without tribunal consent underscores the need for contemporaneous project records, good programme management, and early legal engagement when disputes begin to crystallise.
  • Consider HEAP for standalone, lower complexity disputes: HEAP may be significantly more cost-effective than a full ICC arbitration.
  • Choose arbitrators carefully: given the tighter disclosure framework, parties should carry out thorough conflict checks when nominating arbitrators and should compile their disclosure lists thoughtfully.

Author: Emma Flood, Senior Associate. www.arthurcox.com

Follow Irish building magazine on LinkedIn for the latest news and updates.